U.S. judge orders Google to hand over emails on foreign server

In a similar case, the US Department of Justice is considering going to the Supreme Court after an appeals court refused to revisit its July 2016 landmark ruling blocking government access to emails stored on Microsoft servers in Ireland. The specific emails that the FBI is requesting for them are part of a domestic fraud investigation.

In the ruling, the judge also wrote that there was "no meaningful interference" in the account holder's "possessory interest" in the data sought in the warrant, Reuters reported Sunday.

Google has used Microsoft's case as an example to challenge the ruling by the magistrate and has stated that it will appeal against the decision and "push back on overbroad warrants".

In line with the Microsoft ruling, Google argued that it had complied with warrants it had received for data the company knew to be stored in the U.S., but that some emails were stored outside the country to improve network performance. USA investigators had issued a search warrant for a drug related case. This opposes to a recent case involving Microsoft in which a Federal Appeal Court concluded that the company didn't need to comply with such orders.

"This court agrees with the Second Circuit's reliance upon Fourth Amendment principles, but respectfully disagrees with the Second Circuit's analysis regarding the location of the seizure and the invasion of privacy", wrote Judge Thomas Rueter in his ruling Friday. The company said that it complies with warrants it had received by handing over data the company knew was stored in the US. The court then felt that SCA did not authorize courts to serve notice, as well as, search of email content stored on foreign servers.

Google also says that the Microsoft case is a precedent that Judge Rueter chose to ignore. Rueter of the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania ruled that the customer emails in question were not protected and Google must surrender the emails.

Google receives about 25,000 data request from U.S authorities relating to criminal matters. Google considers that it is a clear invasion of privacy. That decision was largely applauded by tech companies, privacy groups, .the American Civil Liberties Union and U.S. Chamber of Commerce.

According to a report by Reuters, the judge mentioned that such data transfer from Google's servers overseas "has the potential for invasion of privacy" but the violation doesn't occur until "the time of disclosure in the United States".

Related news:

Hot News

Outpost bill heading for final vote in the Knesset
Feb 07, 2017 - 01:02
Israel's attorney-general has said it is unconstitutional and that he will not defend it at the Supreme Court. Warns Israel to Stop Announcing New West Bank Settlements.

White House Issues Statement After Federal Judge Pauses Travel Ban
Feb 06, 2017 - 01:10
Individuals, organizations, politicians and some states called it unconstitutional religious discrimination against Muslims. The State Department and the Department of Homeland Security said they would comply with the judge's ruling.

Cameroon defeats Egypt to win 5th AFCON title
Feb 06, 2017 - 01:07
Cameroon have won the Africa Cup of Nations courtesy of a dramatic 2-1 victory over Egypt in the final in Libreville this evening. The heroics of Egypt's 44yearold goalkeeper Essam El Hadary helped them edge through to the final on penalties.

isis-killer-beheading-video-story-top Arthur Blank: Matt Ryan will be compensated well
Feb 06, 2017 - 00:59
Maybe Ryan hasn't reinvented himself in Year 8, but he has improved so much that Shanahan became a hot head coaching prospect. I'd expect Brady to feel more of a pass rush during the Super Bowl than he's experienced during the playoffs this year.

U.S. military sends guided-missile destroyer near Yemen
Feb 05, 2017 - 01:49
During a news conference on Thursday, White House spokesperson Sean Spicer falsely claimed that Iran had attacked a U.S. Cole and its crew were the victim of a similar suicide boat attack when it was docked in Yemen in 2000.

isis-killer-beheading-video-story-top Matt Kuchar shines in first round at the Phoenix Open
Feb 05, 2017 - 01:46
An entered Saturday tied with Brendan Steele for the lead at 10 under par, but Steele fell off the pace with a one-under 70. In his three appearances in this tournament, Matsuyama has finished tied for fourth, second and first.

isis-killer-beheading-video-story-top Super Bowl 2017: Watch the commercials
Feb 05, 2017 - 01:46
Sometimes, simple, creative, humorous or emotional ads are the best investment a company can make, even at record high prices. That means that at a cost of $5 million, a 30 second Super Bowl commercial costs between 4 and 5 cents per viewer.

isis-killer-beheading-video-story-top Texas Mayor Jess Herbst Comes Out As Transgender
Feb 05, 2017 - 01:42
She has served the city since 2003, also as alderman and road commissioner - first elected as Jeff Herbst . We're definitely rooting for Jess and wish her a lengthy career in politics.

isis-killer-beheading-video-story-top Wall Street Poised to Profit Under Trump
Feb 04, 2017 - 00:53
Many mortgage and banking industry groups have decried the act, saying it created an onerous regulatory burden. It could also include a dismantling of "orderly liquidation" authority for too-big-to-fail banks.

United States job market is off to a strong start in 2017
Feb 04, 2017 - 00:51
Another 32,000 jobs were added in the financial services sector, notably among real estate and insurance agents. Generated by readers, the comments included herein do not reflect the views and opinions of Rigzone.

isis-killer-beheading-video-story-top SECDEF Mattis meets with South Korean leaders to strengthen alliance
Feb 04, 2017 - 00:43
US President Donald Trump's defence secretary on Friday reaffirmed America's commitment to its mutual defence treaty with Japan. Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Lu Kang yesterday reiterated China's opposition to Thaad, which he said would never change.

isis-killer-beheading-video-story-top Hawkish Trump on Iran: 'Nothing's Off the Table'
Feb 03, 2017 - 00:53
Resolution 2231, which prohibits Iran from building ballistic missiles capable of delivering a nuclear payload. The lack of specifics in Flynn's and Trump's warning could be a miscalculation, the analysts said.

Hornets trade for Miles Plumlee
Feb 03, 2017 - 00:49
Hawes, 28, has appeared in 35 games (one start) for the Hornets this season with averages of 7.3 points and 4.2 rebounds per game. In 16 minutes of playing time per game, he averages 5.2 points and 3.6 rebounds.

In response to Trump, Yad Vashem emphasizes Jewish suffering in the Holocaust
Feb 03, 2017 - 00:47
A Republican senator is criticizing the Trump administration for failing to mention Jews in a statement remembering the Holocaust. However, when he's wrong, good reporting requires the president and his administration get a swift kick in the assets.

MEP holds sign behind Nigel Farage's head saying 'He's lying to you'
Feb 02, 2017 - 00:43
The hand made sign read "he's lying to you" with an arrow pointing upwards to Nigel Farage, who was speaking infront of him. A lot of people really like Nigel Farage.